I have to admit, I have a fondness for third person, past tense in both reading and my own writing. In reading, it's more of a preference. I will read a first person novel, but it has to be really good to capture my interest. I think it's because I enjoy reading about other people and what they're going through and third person perspective allows me to watch them, feel for them whereas first person asks me to become them for a little while, which I find difficult. The difficulty arises because, unless the person is someone I can really identify with, I resist that.
As for writing, I have much the same problem. When I write I imagine a scene and through that imagination I watch my characters act and react, hear what they say, see what they do and write it down. When I try to do the same for first person, I find it difficult not to think of myself when writing 'I'. So I can't see the character. Does that make sense to anyone other than me?
Then we have tense. I've always written in past tense, and have enjoyed reading the same way. However, I've noticed a fondness for using present tense in writing of late and I have to say, unless it's a short story, I find it off-putting. I'm not sure why. I'm usually pretty open to new experiences and as I said, when reading a short story it doesn't bother me so much. But I recently tried to read The Windup Girl by
33 comments:
I'm like you - I vastly prefer third person past tense for both my own reading and writing. It's a little more flexible in reading, and since I've been reading a lot of YA lately, I've had to develop a tolerance - maybe even a fondness - for present tense first person. But I think I prefer third person past tense for the same reasons you do - I would rather be the people-watcher in the mall than pretending I'm in someone else's shoes. I struggle when writing first person because I think it's so much easier to break the show, don't tell rule. (Which is not an iron-clad rule in itself, but definitely a good rule of thumb.)
I also put down The Windup Girl after a few chapters. For me, it wasn't the tense, but the way I could tell that the writer had a thing for the windup girl herself. That put me off a little. I mean, I certainly get crushes on some of my own fictional characters, and erotica definitely has its place, but...I dunno, the sexual nature of her twitching just freaked me out too much. I was probably being judgey though, I really should give the book a second chance.
I prefer 3rd past too, but find myself writing more and more 1st past. For some stories it seems necessary. I hate present tense. It always jars me.
I don't really have a preference when reading. I like both. Depends on the voice.
When writing, third person feels more natural. It comes easier for me. BUT wouldn't you know it, my trilogy I'm working on is in first person. It's just the way the character came to me. Some people find first person easy, but it's a challenge for me. I feel like the voice has to really jump of the page to be interesting. Tough to do.
You're not alone.
I don't mind first person, although novels with more than one first person point of view can get a little . . . tangled.
But I really don't like stories written in the present tense. I suppose it could work for a flash piece. But any story that spans some time just feels wrong in present tense.
Another 3rd person past tense gal here. If I pick up a book and it's written in first person, more than likely I'll put it down. It's just too inside one person's head. I like other POVs.
I love what Annalise said - I'd rather be the people-watcher in the mall than pretending I'm someone else.
I guess I like knowing what other people are thinking. One-sided gets boring.
@Annalise, I didn't even get that far. Still have it on my Kindle, maybe I'll try again when I don't have anything else to read.
@Cat I can understand why it might seem necessary and I've certainly written a few myself that I thought needed 1st person, but I was never comfortable there and I think it showed in my writing.
@LG I don't find it easy at all. It's definitely a challenge, and when it's done well and the character is someone I can find some way to identify with I can really enjoy it.
@Meredith, I agree, I think it's the length. I can read them and enjoy them at a short length but over time it makes reading seem like work.
@Tameri yeah that's pretty much me too. I like to watch the characters rather than become them. Each to their own, of course, and there are some great first person novels out there. I have to say though, that my personal favourites over the years have all been 3rd person.
I don't really feel one way or the other about tense, I think you have to consider it on a case by case basis. Have you considered reading a more established writer or story in present tense to see if it works better for you?
mood
Moody Writing
@mooderino
I haven't, Moody, but I have read some shorts that I thought worked really well.
I think what affects me is that it seems like someone talking to me rather than me experiencing what's going on through the POV of a character. I've heard way too many people in conversation saying 'she walks up to me and says...' and that's what I feel that the character (or the writer) is doing. I think I just need to become accustomed to it as a means of storytelling.
This is a great little post, Cheryl, and certainly one to think about. I'm a huge fan of past tense, too. Yet, I've also become a fan of first-person perspective, and those two always seemed at odds to me. In a first-person story, past tense always felt as if the character was telling me the story from the future, like a "One time I did this thing..." kind-of tone, and that always ruins some part of tension for me. Why? Because if the character's telling me the story from the future, I know they're still alive to share the story with me.
Regardless, I can't fathom writing in present tense! My writing always fades back into the past. Just a habit I can't get over.
I have to say, I read a couple of stories recently that really blew me away and they were in third person, present tense. So it definitely depends on the writer. Although they were chapters of a novel they were also single stand-alone stories that the novel ties together. They are wonderfully rich with imagery and emotion and the writers' voice is poetic and original. Can't say any more than that for now, I'm afraid, because the work isn't published, but when (not if) it is, I'll be plugging the book as much as I can because it gets me right where it matters.
Cheryl, Great post with some interesting responses. i tend to write in third person past tense, but I have written some short stories in first person past. I did try a third person present tense short story as an experiment. i wanted to create the urgency created from present tense. So far, no one has been willing to publish it, so I've considered revising it to past tense. If it loses it's intensity, I might keep it in present.
I've heard a lot people say they hate reading present tense. At the SCWW conference this year a high-ranking editor from TOR discouraged present tense. He said it was the writer's effort to force the reader's interpretation of their story. Some food for thought, anyway.
Barbara, thanks for the input and thought-provoking comments.
As for your story, well, perhaps you just didn't find the right market for it yet. I do think it works well for short fiction and it seems to be popular in some publications.
It's actually a nice and helpful piece of info. I am happy that you just shared this useful info with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.
Here is my web-site www.natural-remedies-for-erectile-dysfunction.com
Hello theгe! I could have swοrn I've visited your blog before but after browsing through some of the articles I realized it's new to me.
Anуways, I'm definitely delighted I came across it and I'll bе book-marκing it аnd cheсking bаck
frequentlу!
Stop by my blog post : http://Hotmailcorreo.webs.com
Highly energetic blog, I loved that bit. Will there be a part 2?
Check out my blog post - www.examiner.com
Hey! I realize this is somewhat off-topic however I had to ask.
Does running a well-established website such as yours take a large
amount of work? I am completely new to operating a blog however I do
write in my journal everyday. I'd like to start a blog so I will be able to share my own experience and feelings online. Please let me know if you have any recommendations or tips for brand new aspiring blog owners. Thankyou!
Feel free to visit my blog post act Registration deadlines
I'm not positive the place you are getting your information, but good topic. I needs to spend a while finding out more or working out more. Thank you for excellent info I used to be in search of this information for my mission.
Take a look at my blog ; doctor-detail.com
always i used to read smaller articles or reviews that also
clear their motive, and that is also happening with this piece of writing which I
am reading here.
Visit my web-site: acura rdx used
Search for professional Internet Marketing Companies India and
let an experienced copy writer craft eye-grabbing
ad content for your business. By using the
autoresponder, you have been in front of a potential customer for five
days. - Page 16 -.
Feel free to surf to my web site :: Internet Marketing Coach
Also see my webpage :: Internet Marketing Tips
With the increasing fan base your product sale will also considerably increase
and your marketing objectives will be easily achieved. Facebook fans and you can get facebook fans cheap if you
follow the link at the bottom of this article.
There are many ways of doing this and this article take a look at some of them.
My webpage - get facebook fans
Wrap it in gauze and put it in the infected area.
Include about three to 4 tablespoons of vinegar to a bathtub stuffed with a tiny sum of warm h2o and only bathe in it
for fifteen to twenty minutes. That will also help restore the balance in your body and get things back on
track.
Check out my page preventing yeast infection and antibiotics
my website - can you have yeast infection after hysterectomy
In that case, this kind of question should not be taken
from any show telecasted in specific country. * Team answer sheets -
Basically a grid lined A4 type sheet with answer write in numbered boxes and a line on top for the team name.
The food is decent and the drink specials on Tuesdays include $2.
Feel free to surf to my weblog :: Fun Pub Quiz Names
A few weeks before the party said the girl's birthday we were going to youth club on Saturday night and the theme was horror. Clearly say the details similar to day, go out with, time and locale for the event. Remember to get awesome free samples kids printable birthday invitations and wording to help get the hype going for the party.
my site: 18th birthday party ideas
These ads are then distributed to their network of websites.
But the real fact is that all the Youtube views and comments are genuine and come from
real Youtube users. The most frequently asked question in this regard is how
you can easily buy You - Tube Views.
Feel free to surf to my web blog :: increase youtube views
On Sunday nights Erin Jaimes hosts a blues jam where anyone from Alan Haynes to Gary Clark, Jr.
You must definitely be planning to make it special and memorable by keeping a good theme,
ordering the best food and choosing the best games.
The Bull's Head Pub, Bangkok.
Have a look at my page; pub quiz anagrams
my page: free pub quiz and answers
This is usually considered a fun and effective learning method in general.
As an alternative, it will most likely be far more powerful for you to learn about audio and chord
idea. Pretend that we are palming an egg and
keep your arms relaxed and fingers curled.
Here is my site: jar of hearts piano chords and lyrics
Also see my webpage: virtual piano chords and scales
The best wedding planning i - Pad app is the one that is easy to use and has all of
the organizational tools needed to plan an awesome wedding.
Instead of sending your scanned invitation, it would be great if you create your own
wedding website and invite your friends and relatives.
4.
Here is my blog post :: wedding website album
In other words, they go against the grain of the careers their parents had.
Local country clubs are offering trivia fun for
as little as forty dollars per couple. Theme
Format: It is almost like standard format of the pub quiz.
My webpage :: funny pub quiz names
A few weeks before the party said the girl's birthday we were going to youth club on Saturday night and the theme was horror. There are tons of places online that will help you in this regard. A kids birthday party games party at the park can be a blast on a very low budget.
my web site 13th birthday Party ideas
Some were practical, of course, but others were psychological and emotional.
Anna had been looking through my phone while I was naked.
Ask your local club to run this for you.
Here is my blog fun pub quiz names
providing relevant content for your blog. Of course if you want an internet marketing plan
to actually fulfill its intended function, then it has to be constructed in a competent
manner. Relate to them and they will always come back.
My web site: internet marketing techniques
If you're on a budget have your guests light sparklers as you depart. Fortunately, our minister has neither, and he's
asked very little of us as well. I knew exactly what I wanted for my bridal lingerie,
but I simply couldn't find a place that offered it, complete and in my size.
Also visit my blog ... wedding website affiliate programs
my webpage > wedding website about me
Chords introduce harmony into music and it is the effects created by chords
that produce the inspiration behind so much music and make it so satisfying both to listen to
and to play. So you want to learn how to play the piano.
It is very soothing to hear the sound of piano and based on such vast change of scales,
a song sounds so melodious.
Also visit my weblog piano chords apologize timbaland
My web page: piano chords and request
Post a Comment